THE WORLD RECASTIndependent historical writing

A thematic collection · 1918–1939

Nations, Borders and Belonging

Who belonged to the nation—and who had the power to decide?

A new border could promise freedom while leaving people uncertain about their place within it. The replacement of empires by states claiming national legitimacy raised questions that treaties alone could not resolve: who constituted the nation, which communities could claim self-government and what protection remained for those whose identities did not fit the official account?

This collection begins with Austria-Hungary’s collapse and the choices made at Paris, then follows the competing national and revolutionary claims confronted during Russia’s civil wars. Palestine brings rival national aspirations into the same territory under British mandatory rule. Amritsar exposes the unequal standing of colonized people within an empire whose claims to justice were challenged by its own violence.

The essays approach belonging through political power as well as identity. Recognition of a nation did not guarantee equal rights to everyone living within its claimed territory, and a demand for national freedom could coexist with exclusions inside the movement advancing it. The longer histories of Canada, India and Türkiye extend these questions beyond 1939, while keeping Dominion autonomy, anti-colonial independence and Indigenous sovereignty distinct.

Read across the stories

A suggested reading sequence

  1. The Empire That Disappeared: The Collapse of Austria-Hungary

    Begin with the collapse of Austria-Hungary, where national independence brought new states alongside unresolved disputes over territory, minorities and belonging.

    Read on Leaflet
  2. Paris, 1919: Who Had the Right to Decide the World’s Future?

    Examine who could speak for a nation at Paris, whose claims shaped the settlement and whose future was decided by others.

    Read on Leaflet
  3. The Revolution That Survived: Russia’s Civil Wars and the Birth of the Soviet Union

    Follow the intersection of national independence movements, civil wars and revolutionary state-building across the former Russian Empire.

    Read on Leaflet
  4. Palestine Under the Mandate: The Great Arab Revolt

    Consider Palestinian Arab and Zionist national aspirations, British mandatory authority and competing claims to the same country.

    Read on Leaflet
  5. Amritsar: The Massacre That Shook the British Empire

    Examine the gulf between imperial claims to justice and the treatment of Indian civilians, and its consequences for the struggle for self-government.

    Read on Leaflet
  6. Four Empires Fell. What Replaced Them?

    Examine the successor states, minorities and displaced communities created by the collapse of four empires.

    Read on Leaflet
  7. The Empire That Survived by Changing Its Rules

    Examine national autonomy alongside Indigenous dispossession, racial exclusion and competing forms of Commonwealth belonging.

    Read on Leaflet
  8. 1919: The Year the World Refused to Obey

    Ask whose claims to nationhood received recognition and whose demands the victors rejected.

    Read on Leaflet
  9. From Sultan to Republic: How Turkey Overturned the Postwar Settlement

    Follow contested sovereignty, population displacement and the making of a new national state.

    Read on Leaflet
  10. How Fascism Entered Government: Mussolini and the Destruction of Italian Democracy

    Explore how Fascism defined national loyalty through obedience and excluded Italians who resisted its claim to speak for the nation.

    Read on Leaflet

The New World Order · 1918 to the present

Follow the longer history

Place these stories in time

Return to the events behind this collection, with sources and links to the longer stories.